Many organisations are delivering leadership development programmes that are at best poor value for money, and at worst, a drain on financial resources and individuals. Failures in leadership lie at the heart of many newsworthy recent and current crises, even though a great deal of money is being spent on programmes that purport to develop leadership. With so much investment, why is good leadership so elusive?
There are many reasons why leadership development fails in its aims, but there are some very common causes:
Six common causes of failure in leadership development
- Believing there’s a blueprint for good leadership
- Development based on leadership competency models
- Inherent contradictions within the development curriculum
- Trying to train leaders
- Providing tools and techniques for ‘leadership’
- Delivering management development and calling it leadership development
If any or all of the above are features of your leadership development offering, you may, unwittingly, be doing more harm than good.
How do we know?
We have a team that is fully committed to leadership development, led by the former Director of the Management Development Unit at Cranfield School of Management who steered the School into the top 4 providers of tailored in-company Executive Development in the world. During this period, the team created an internal Faculty Development Programme that significantly enhanced the design and delivery skills of the School’s development professionals.
Typically, these seasoned professionals said of this programme that it gave them, “The chance to rethink first principles and address ‘live’ teaching issues. The course has answered some questions about the reasons some things have not worked.”
Since becoming independent in 2001, we have been involved in consulting on leadership development with clients such as Citigroup, The European Investment Fund, Barclays Capital, Sara Lee, Darlington Borough Council, AMEC and many more. Our work has taken us across Europe, and into North and South America, the Far East, and Australia.
Our experience has enabled us both to publish on learning and leadership, and to identify why some leadership development is powerful and effective, whilst some is well-meaning but ineffective.
Leadership development audit
We have over 20 years’ experience in auditing and enhancing leadership development programmes for our clients. Our leadership development audit service is now being offered to you as a flexible package.
The audit comprises a number of elements from which you can select as appropriate for your own context.
Review
The initial stage is a review of your current leadership development portfolio. We explore with you its aims, content, style, design and outcomes, including all feedback you have already collected. In many instances, this stage can already highlight issues to be addressed. An experienced, objective and dispassionate review of any programme can produce significant benefit for you, the internal reputation of L&D, and your organisation.
Observe
What is written is not always an accurate reflection of what is experienced. We have observed many hundreds of leadership development activities, sharing with participants not what is being presented, but what is being experienced. We see things through the eyes of the target audience, not those of the deliverers.
Interview
Interviewing key stakeholders in the development of leadership can be a powerful way of gaining insight into the wide variety of impressions they have both of leadership itself, and of the development on offer. We have experience in interviewing and engaging with senior leaders, HR and L&D professionals, participants, and providers, both internal and external.
Report and recommendations
Our audit report will provide recommendations on two fronts: recommendations for enhancement of management development activities, and recommendations for enhancement of leadership development. In many organisations, these are jumbled together, and send out contradictory messages for participants. Our expertise is in both management and leadership development, and we can show why and how these two need to be clearly differentiated.
Design
Designing for learning has been one of our key strengths for many years. We work with our clients on drawing up robust and effective learning design, taking into account not only the desired outcomes for any programme or activity, but also how the design will be experienced by people going through the programme.
Developing the developers
Designing, developing and delivering effective leadership development requires skills and capabilities that are different from those needed for training or for management development. Our Develop the Developers workshops transfer those appropriate skills and capabilities to your team, to enable you to build further on our audit service, and help ensure that your leadership development offerings continue to deliver value for money.
As the Head of Learning and Development at Barclays Capital said at the time of our Developing the Developers programme: “The programme is not meant simply to enhance our already highly developed skills. It is there to put us at the leading edge of Development and Performance Management. It will provide us with a set of tools, a methodology, and, moreover, a way of thinking about our business which will mean we can become a centre of excellence others will want to emulate.”
WHY NOT GET A TASTE OF HOW WE CAN HELP?
We are running a half-day leadership audit programme
The workshop will be enlightening, interactive and practical. We will explore case material of real development programmes, showing how they can inadvertently send out mixed messages.
In addition, we will invite you to send us your questions and issues on leadership development before the event, so that we can be sure we address what is important to you on the day.
If you would like to know more….
The workshop will cover, amongst other topics as requested:
- How leadership is different from management. Leadership is not another term for senior management, but is fundamentally different from management, and depends for success on a leader’s character, integrity, and credibility, not upon his or her status or formal authority.
- Why leadership development therefore needs to be fundamentally different from management development. Management development seeks to help managers acquire the skills, attitudes, and competences appropriate for his or her job and organisational context. Leadership development helps individuals develop their own, unique leadership qualities through deep exploration of their characters, values and strategies for leading.
- Why the six common causes of failure do cause failure. Each of these causes of failure is built upon well-meaning attempts to deliver value. We will show how and why each of these is inappropriate and potentially harmful to the development of genuine leadership.
- Practical learning design. We will share some of our experience of designing integrated, learner-centred and rigorous programmes both of management development and leadership development, and explain why they work.
- Introduction to the Leadership Compass. Leadership manifests itself in many different and often apparently contradictory forms. The Leadership Compass enables developers to help guide different individuals in different directions, whilst enabling their organisations to capitalise upon the wide range of leadership capabilities represented within the Leadership compass.
- Motivations – how these link leadership and learning. For a leader to be effective, he or she needs to understand his or her own deep motivations and drivers, and be able to recognise what drives others. We will briefly touch on how a deeper appreciation of differing motivations influences both leadership and leadership development.
- What next? Following the half-day session, we will be offering a follow-up initial discussion of how what we have covered can be turned to your benefit in your organisation, through an initial visit or conference call focusing on your programme or programmes of both management and leadership development.
The workshop is to be held in Central London on Friday 1st June.
Coffee and Registration at 9.00am
Workshop commences at 9.30am
Workshop Finishes at 1.00pm with a light buffet lunch
There is a charge of £95.00+ VAT per person.
Places are limited, so please book early to avoid disappointment
Places can be booked by emailing Michelle.McArthur-Morgan.